youtube-competitor-analyzer Evolving Log
Overview
- Skill: youtube-competitor-analyzer
- Task ID: T-mnizll6i
- Start Score: 84.7
- Final Score: 91.2
- Iterations: 3
- Status: PASSED
Iteration 0 — Baseline
Date: 2026-04-03 Score: 84.7 / 100 Action: Loaded existing SKILL.md and performed initial evaluation against benchmark.md and test_dataset.json.
Dimension Scores: | Dimension | Score | |-----------|-------| | Accuracy | 17.3 | | Completeness | 17.5 | | Insight | 15.8 | | Structure | 16.6 | | Efficiency | 16.9 |
Weak Dimensions: Accuracy, Completeness, Insight, Structure, Efficiency
Key Issues Identified:
forUsernameincorrectly recommended for/c/nameURLs (accuracy issue).- No subscriber growth estimation method provided (accuracy/completeness).
- Insight generation only had a generic O-I-R framework, lacking scenario templates (insight weakness).
- No standardized response formats for quota questions or API sequences (structure weakness).
- No explicit low-quota handling example (efficiency weakness).
Iteration 1 — Core Fixes + Formats
Date: 2026-04-03 Score: 88.3 / 100 (+3.6)
Changes Applied:
- Fixed
forUsernamelimitation; modern URLs now usesearch.list. - Added subscriber growth estimation transparency (Methods A/B/C).
- Created Insight Template Library (Templates 1-5) with trigger conditions.
- Added Competitive Positioning Matrix instructions.
- Added Quota Response Format and 3-Tier Dynamic Quota Downgrade Strategy.
- Added API Sequence Response Format with unit-cost tracking.
- Integrated industry benchmarks from
knowhow_base.md. - Added yoga niche keywords.
Dimension Delta: | Dimension | Change | |-----------|--------| | Accuracy | +1.0 | | Completeness | +0.7 | | Insight | +1.0 | | Structure | +0.8 | | Efficiency | +0.5 |
Notes: Biggest gains in Accuracy (URL fix) and Insight (templates). Still 1.7 points short of 90.
Iteration 2 — Rules + Checklists
Date: 2026-04-03 Score: 89.3 / 100 (+1.0)
Changes Applied:
- Added URL / Handle Parsing Decision Tree for systematic discovery handling.
- Enforced Quantification Rule: every recommendation must contain numbers, deadlines, or thresholds.
- Added Mini-Insights for Technical Requests to improve discover/filter/API outputs.
- Added Pre-Execution Checklist (7-point self-validation).
Dimension Delta: | Dimension | Change | |-----------|--------| | Accuracy | +0.0 | | Completeness | +0.0 | | Insight | +1.0 | | Structure | +0.1 | | Efficiency | +0.4 |
Notes: Insight gained from quantification rule and mini-insights. Structure and efficiency improved marginally. Gap to target narrowed to 0.7.
Iteration 3 — Enhanced Insight Framework + Final Polish
Date: 2026-04-03 Score: 91.2 / 100 (+1.9)
Changes Applied:
- Added Low-Quota Working Example (1,500 units exact response).
- Added Discover Response Format for discover/filter requests.
- Added Metric Interpretation Examples.
- Added Enhanced Insight Framework (v1.3):
- Strategic Insight Ladder (Data → Pattern → Strategy → Action)
- Quantified Recommendation Formula with quality examples
- Context-Aware Insight Templates 6-8
- Automated Insight Triggers table
- 6-point Insight Quality Checklist
Dimension Delta: | Dimension | Change | |-----------|--------| | Accuracy | +0.2 | | Completeness | +0.2 | | Insight | +1.8 | | Structure | +0.3 | | Efficiency | +0.1 |
Notes: Massive insight boost (+1.8) from Enhanced Insight Framework pushed the skill past 90. All test cases now score 88+ with 10/12 at 90+.
Final State
Score: 91.2 / 100 Target: 90 Result: PASSED
Test Case Summary
| ID | Type | Score |
|---|---|---|
| test-01 | end-to-end | 93 |
| test-02 | discover | 92 |
| test-03 | filter | 90 |
| test-04 | analyze | 93 |
| test-05 | gap | 91 |
| test-06 | quota | 90 |
| test-07 | api | 94 |
| test-08 | report | 94 |
| test-09 | insight | 88 |
| test-10 | edge-case | 92 |
| test-11 | discover | 88 |
| test-12 | metric | 93 |
Next Action
DEPLOY — Skill meets or exceeds all benchmark criteria.