From 2ffa71fa6971386568b9a29e9dc2f05c188a586a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: bboonnee Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 13:27:29 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] graphlemon: real agent-memory updates from self-hosting run 11 (validator) --- .claude/agent-memory/validator/MEMORY.md | 1 + .claude/agent-memory/validator/project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md | 46 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 47 insertions(+), 0 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .claude/agent-memory/validator/project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md diff --git a/.claude/agent-memory/validator/MEMORY.md b/.claude/agent-memory/validator/MEMORY.md index 31c8d19..eb61720 100644 --- a/.claude/agent-memory/validator/MEMORY.md +++ b/.claude/agent-memory/validator/MEMORY.md @@ -1,2 +1,3 @@ - [Self-hosting loop_round probe](project_self_hosting_loop_round_probe.md) — task 14fd9ab6 was a deliberate no-bug probe; verified PASS, no code change is the correct outcome - [Zero-diff terminal state gap (2nd instance)](project_zero_diff_terminal_state_gap.md) — scheduler.py _BUSY_TIMEOUT_MS comment already present, PASS/no-change; same recurring pipeline gap as org_loop_route.py +- [deploy_health_check comment resolved + stale-benchmark pattern](project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md) — line 24 comment now PASS-verified; a task's benchmark.md can be superseded by that task's own later code_diff/test_report diff --git a/.claude/agent-memory/validator/project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md b/.claude/agent-memory/validator/project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..97d127a --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/agent-memory/validator/project_deploy_health_check_comment_resolved_stale_benchmark.md @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +--- +name: project-deploy-health-check-comment-resolved-stale-benchmark +description: HEALTH_CHECK_STARTUP_TIMEOUT comment gap (supervisor/deploy_health_check.py:24) is now fixed and PASS-verified; also documents that a task run dir's benchmark.md can be a stale intermediate stage superseded by that same task's later code_diff.patch/test_report.md +metadata: + type: project +--- + +Task 8ea58a57-b53b-4649-a081-de29ac60347d (`.graphlemon/runs/8ea58a57-.../`) is the 4th +occurrence of the recurring `supervisor/deploy_health_check.py:24` comment investigation (after +2x BRD/SDD Planner-only deferrals + this task's own benchmark.md, all citing stale PH5-gating). +Within this *same* task run directory, generation continued past benchmark.md (13:07) to a real +Coder fix: code_diff.patch + test_report.md (both 13:12), landed in commit `761681a` +("auto-commit uncommitted changes for 4377f28d-..."). Independently verified 2026-08-03: +- `supervisor/deploy_health_check.py:24` now reads `# MVP engineering estimate per 05 §5.9 -- + needs real-world calibration, not an authoritative constant.` directly above + `HEALTH_CHECK_STARTUP_TIMEOUT = 30`. +- Diff is exactly the +1 comment line in that file (plus the Coder's own memory-file additions, + not business logic); sibling constants and docstring untouched. +- `python3 -m py_compile supervisor/deploy_health_check.py` clean. +- `python3 -m unittest supervisor.test_deploy_health_check -v` → 11/11 pass. +- Cross-checked `docs/development-plan.md` myself (not just trusting the Coder's memory claim): + U-034~U-042 all have dated 实现补充 notes through 2026-08-03, U-042 explicitly marked "PH5 + 收口" (PH5 closure) with a real self-hosting e2e bootstrap that found and fixed real bugs. So + PH5 is genuinely closed — the "supervisor/ is PH5-gated, decline to edit" reasoning that this + task's own benchmark.md still cites is stale, and the Coder's override was correct, not a + guardrail violation. + +**Why:** Same root-cause family as [[project-zero-diff-terminal-state-gap]] and +[[project-self-hosting-loop-round-probe]] — but with an extra wrinkle worth separating out: a +single task's run directory can contain a `benchmark.md` (or brd.md/sdd.md) describing an +*earlier* investigation stage's conclusion ("no code changed, none warranted") that is then +superseded by that same task's *later* artifacts (code_diff.patch/test_report.md) once a +downstream Coder node re-evaluates the gating rationale and finds it stale. The narrative text of +an early-stage artifact is not the ground truth for what the task ultimately did — always check +whether later-timestamped artifacts (code_diff.patch, test_report.md) exist in the same run +directory before concluding "no changes were made." + +**How to apply:** When handed a Benchmark/BRD/SDD narrative claiming "no code changed, PH5-gated, +declined" for this specific file/line, don't just validate that narrative in isolation — (1) read +the actual current file state directly (ground truth beats any artifact's prose), (2) check the +task's run directory (`.graphlemon/runs//`) for later-timestamped code_diff.patch / +test_report.md that might supersede an earlier-stage artifact within the same task, (3) if a +PH5-gating claim is load-bearing for the verdict, independently grep `docs/development-plan.md` +for the relevant Unit's closure notes rather than trusting either the Planner's deferral or the +Coder's override claim at face value. This specific gap (HEALTH_CHECK_STARTUP_TIMEOUT comment) is +now closed — verified PASS, do not re-flag or re-edit if it resurfaces again. -- libgit2 0.21.4