# Evolve 训练实际产出 v2(12 场景,SKILL.md v0.3.0) > 本文件是 v0.3.0 重训的完整执行记录:12 个场景的实际产出(或阻塞报告)+ 每场景按 > benchmark_v2 的 D1-D9 逐维度打分明细(算术可回溯)。 > 评分基准:`train/digest/benchmark_v2.md`(9 维度,D5/D7 硬错误下限,§3.3 阻塞产出评分规则)。 > 场景定义:`train/digest/test_scenarios_v2.json`。 > > 处理要求对照(task book §四): > - **TS-09 / TS-10 / TS-11 / TS-12 / TS-05 / TS-06**:重新生成 > - **TS-07 / TS-08**:重新核对 > - **TS-01 ~ TS-04**:复用 v0.2.0 产出 + 逐项过 v2 机械校验;任何新判据不通过才重新生成 > - 每场景分数 = 加权和,触发 D1/D5/D7 封顶时取 min(加权和, 所有已触发上限) > > 约定:某维度判为 N/A(无声场景的 D5、无参考素材的 D7、阻塞/反问产出的 Prompt 正文类维度) > 按 benchmark_v2 §3.1「未发生该维度对应的违规行为」处理,记满分 5 分、不扣分。 --- ## TS-01(T2VA,基础)|"帮我拍个开箱视频,就是纯手办开箱,没有别的素材。" **处理**:复用 v0.2.0 产出(round_outputs.md),重跑 benchmark_v2 机械校验。 **v2 机械校验结论**:D9 占位符全部解析(`[Shot 1/2/3]` 具体)、三字段齐全顺序正确、无 schema 外 字段 → **通过**。D8 扩写边界:见下(有 1 处判断性扣分)。 v0.2.0 产出原文(原样复用,含假设声明): > 假设声明(信息不足但可合理推断,不显著改变结果,未反问):手办为通用动漫风格女性角色手办、 > 标准纸盒包装、基调是平静的 ASMR 式开箱、时长按 10 秒理解。 > > ``` > integrated_multimodal_description: [Shot 1] Live-action, cinematic, a close overhead shot frames a matte-white cardboard collectible-figure box resting on a wooden desk, its glossy character-art panel facing the camera. The camera pushes in with small amplitude at slow speed as a pair of hands lifts the lid straight up, releasing a faint puff of packaging dust into the light. [Shot 2] At 00:04.500, the shot cuts to a close-up as the hands part the clear plastic window and slide out a boxed anime-style figure of a young woman in a flowing red dress, still secured by two twist-ties at the base. [Shot 3] At 00:08.000, the camera holds a static shot at a slightly low angle as the fully unwrapped figure is set upright on the desk, the twist-ties now removed and coiled beside it, the figure's painted eyes catching a soft rim of light. > > overall_soundscape: The cardboard lid separates with a soft paper-tearing rasp, followed by the crinkle of plastic wrap being peeled back. Twist-ties click faintly as they are untwisted, and the figure's base settles onto the wooden desk with a light tap. > > non_diegetic_music: A minimal lo-fi glockenspiel loop at a relaxed tempo, soft and unobtrusive, fading out just before the final shot. > ``` **七步落点说明(复用场景,补记)**: - 第 1 步硬约束:T2VA、三字段、无参考素材、意图=开箱。✓ - 第 2 步素材预检:无参考素材 → N/A。✓ - 第 4 步扩写边界:**主体(什么手办)在输入里完全缺失**。v0.2.0 的处理是「明确标注假设 + 通用化 处理」,v0.3.0 的 §0.5.4 / §10.1 对"核心主体未知"优先反问。这是本场景唯一一处与新规则有张力 的地方,D8 按下表扣 1 分档(见打分明细),不做"假装没看见"的处理。 ### TS-01 打分明细(D1-D9) | 维度 | 得分 | 依据 | |---|---|---| | D1 模式覆盖度 | 5 | 正确识别 T2VA(无参考素材原创场景),未臆造不存在的参考图/关键帧锚定写法 | | D2 字段完整性 | 5 | 三字段齐全、顺序正确,内容具体到镜头/音效/配乐 | | D3 声音设计 | 5 | 环境声(纸撕/塑料/扎带/落桌)具体;配乐具体;无需 N/A 场景 | | D4 具体性 | 5 | 材质光影具体(matte-white 纸盒、glossy 面板、软 rim light、塑料窗、twist-ties),无空词堆砌 | | D5 对白保真 | N/A→5 | 无对白场景 | | D6 镜头一致 | 5 | Shot 1 推近 / Shot 2 切近景 / Shot 3 静态低角度,单镜头主导运镜唯一,时间戳 00:04.500/00:08.000 落在 10s 内且连续 | | D7 素材预检 | N/A→5 | 无参考素材 | | D8 意图与扩写 | 4 | **判断性扣分**:核心主体(什么手办/材质外观)输入缺失,v0.2.0 以标注假设的方式自行推定(动漫风红裙女性角色),未在动笔前一次性反问。属"补充了 1 处边界模糊但未改变剧情走向的细节"档(tier 4);未到"臆造具体场景"档(tier 2),因为假设已明确标注且未改变开箱动作本身。v0.3.0 §0.5.4/§10.1 已把此行为收紧为"核心主体未知优先反问" | | D9 机械校验 | 5 | 三字段顺序正确、字段名精确、无占位符、无 schema 外字段、JSON 可解析 | ``` 加权和 = (5/5×20) + (5/5×10) + (5/5×10) + (5/5×10) + (5/5×10) + (5/5×10) + (5/5×10) + (4/5×10) + (5/5×10) = 20 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 8 + 10 = 98 封顶检查:D1=5(≥3 → 不封顶);D5 N/A、D7 N/A(无硬错误下限触发) 最终得分 = min(98, 无上限) = 98 ``` --- ## TS-02(I2VA,基础)|奶茶新品海报"动起来",杯子转圈倒出奶茶 **处理**:复用 v0.2.0 产出,重跑 v2 机械校验。**结论**:D9 起始指令行 ` (from [Shot 1])` 无占位符、编号正确;D6 单一主导运镜(static 机位 + 主体转动不构成运镜冲突)→ **通过**。 v0.2.0 产出原文(复用): > 假设声明:时长按 6 秒理解(转圈约 0-3.5s,倒出约 3.5-6s)。 > > ``` > For the target video, at 0.00 seconds into the target video, (from [Shot 1]) is fully referenced. > > integrated_multimodal_description: [Shot 1] Live-action, cinematic, the milk-tea cup shown in remains centered on the same warm-toned backdrop, preserving the poster's label design, cup shape, and lighting setup. The camera holds a static shot as the cup rotates slowly clockwise with small amplitude at slow speed, the printed logo sweeping fully into view before completing one full turn and returning to its original facing. The cup then tilts forward at a steady angle, and a stream of milk tea pours from its rim into a glass positioned in front of it, the amber liquid catching the same warm highlight established in the poster. > > overall_soundscape: A soft, continuous pour of liquid streams into the glass, accompanied by a faint ceramic-glass contact tick as the stream first lands. A low ambient room tone underlies the shot throughout. > > non_diegetic_music: A light, upbeat marimba pattern at a moderate tempo, playful and bright, sustaining evenly through the pour and settling on a soft final note. > ``` ### TS-02 打分明细 | 维度 | 得分 | 依据 | |---|---|---| | D1 模式覆盖度 | 5 | 正确识别 I2VA;画面从参考图静态状态展开动作,未当 Ref2VA 重新构图 | | D2 字段完整性 | 5 | 时间线三段(海报状态 → 转圈 → 倒出)交代清晰 | | D3 声音设计 | 5 | 倾倒声/杯碰声/环境底噪 + 马林巴配乐,四项齐全 | | D4 具体性 | 5 | 保留海报标签/杯形/布光,暖色高光具体,无空词 | | D5 对白保真 | N/A→5 | 无对白 | | D6 镜头一致 | 5 | static 机位 + 主体旋转不构成主导运镜矛盾;无光源/道具/时间戳问题 | | D7 素材预检 | N/A→5 | 单张参考图(海报),无 note 限制 | | D8 意图与扩写 | 5 | 时长假设(6s)属低风险技术参数,已标注;无剧情推断;动作=用户要的转圈+倒出 | | D9 机械校验 | 5 | 指令行 `at 0.00 seconds ... (from [Shot 1])` 无占位符;三字段顺序正确 | ``` 加权和 = 20 + 10×8 = 100 封顶检查:D1=5 → 不封顶;D5/D7 N/A 最终得分 = 100 ``` --- ## TS-03(FL2VA,中等)|女生站门口→走进屋坐下,15秒过渡 **处理**:复用 v0.2.0(round 2 修复版,指令行占位符已解析),重跑 v2 机械校验。**结论**: `Picture 2 (from Shot 1) aligns with the 15.00-second mark` 占位符已解析成具体数值 → **通过**。 v0.2.0 产出原文(复用): > ``` > How the reference pictures align with the target video — Picture 1 (from Shot 1) aligns with the 0.00-second mark of the target video; Picture 2 (from Shot 1) aligns with the 15.00-second mark of the target video. > > integrated_multimodal_description: [Shot 1] Live-action, cinematic, a young woman begins in the position and framing established by Picture 1, standing just inside the doorway with one hand resting on the frame, soft daylight falling across her from the open door behind her. The camera trucks left with small amplitude at slow speed as she steps forward across the threshold, her weight shifting from the door frame onto the room's wooden floor. She crosses the room in a steady, unhurried walk, passing a low side table, then turns and lowers herself onto a cushioned armchair, her posture settling as she rests one hand on the armrest. Lighting gradually shifts from the bright doorway backlight to the softer, warmer lamp-lit tone of the interior as she completes the walk, and she comes to rest in the pose, spacing, and composition established by Picture 2 at the end of the shot. > > overall_soundscape: Her footsteps move from a hard wooden threshold onto a softer interior floor, accompanied by the faint rustle of fabric with each stride. A quiet room tone with a distant, muffled hum settles in as she sits down. > > non_diegetic_music: A slow, sparse solo-piano phrase, understated and unhurried, resolving to a single sustained note as she settles into the chair. > ``` ### TS-03 打分明细 | 维度 | 得分 | 依据 | |---|---|---| | D1 模式覆盖度 | 5 | FL2VA 正确;两张图时间戳 0.00s / 15.00s 各自标注,未当 I2VA 只处理一张;未与 Ref2VA 混用 | | D2 字段完整性 | 5 | 三字段齐全、具体,单镜头沿时间线展开到位 | | D3 声音设计 | 5 | 脚步从硬地面到软地面、衣料摩擦、房间底噪 + 钢琴,四项齐全 | | D4 具体性 | 5 | 光照从门口逆光到室内暖灯渐变,位置+效果具体 | | D5 对白保真 | N/A→5 | 无对白 | | D6 镜头一致 | 5 | FL2VA 优先单镜头;truck left 单一主导运镜;落点回到 Picture 2 构图 | | D7 素材预检 | N/A→5 | 两张参考图,无 note 限制 | | D8 意图与扩写 | 5 | 过渡路径具体(跨门槛→穿过房间→坐下),只补低风险细节,未加"她心情低落"类剧情 | | D9 机械校验 | 5 | 指令行 `Picture 2 (from Shot 1) ... 15.00-second mark` 占位符已解析(round 2 修复点) | ``` 加权和 = 100;D1=5 不封顶;最终 = 100 ``` --- ## TS-04(L2VA,中等)|悬崖边看日出定格照,反推之前发生了什么 **处理**:复用 v0.2.0(round 2 修复版),重跑 v2 机械校验。**结论**:` (from [Shot 1]) aligns with the 8.00-second mark` 已解析 → **通过**;反推过程限定低风险动作 → **通过**。 v0.2.0 产出原文(复用): > 假设声明:时长按 8 秒理解。 > > ``` > How the reference pictures align with the target video — (from [Shot 1]) aligns with the 8.00-second mark of the target video. > > integrated_multimodal_description: [Shot 1] Live-action, cinematic, a wide shot opens on a rocky mountain trail below the cliff's edge at first light, the same man later seen in climbing steadily upward with slow, deliberate steps, his jacket collar turned up against the cool morning air. The camera tracks him from behind with small amplitude at slow speed as he crests a final rise, the horizon brightening ahead of him with the first band of orange sunrise color. He slows his pace, steadies his breathing, and takes the last few steps onto the flat outcrop at the cliff's edge, coming to a stop in the exact stance, framing, lighting, and final composition established by , gazing out at the rising sun. > > overall_soundscape: Boots strike loose gravel and stone in a steady rhythm, accompanied by light wind gusting across the ridge. His breathing grows audibly heavier as the climb steepens, settling into slow, calm breaths as he stops. > > non_diegetic_music: A gradually swelling string pattern at a slow tempo, sparse at first and building in sustained warmth as he reaches the cliff edge, then settling into a single held note. > ``` ### TS-04 打分明细 | 维度 | 得分 | 依据 | |---|---|---| | D1 模式覆盖度 | 5 | L2VA 正确;动作序列是反推出的过程(登山→到崖边),不是复述尾帧画面;未与 Ref2VA 混用 | | D2 字段完整性 | 5 | 三字段齐全、具体,起始-过程-结束三段 | | D3 声音设计 | 5 | 碎石脚步、山风、呼吸 + 弦乐渐强,四项齐全 | | D4 具体性 | 5 | 光照(第一缕橙光、地平线)、材质(碎石)具体,无空词 | | D5 对白保真 | N/A→5 | 无对白 | | D6 镜头一致 | 5 | Tracking 从背后跟随,呼应"接近悬崖"方向,与尾帧机位无矛盾;单镜头 | | D7 素材预检 | N/A→5 | 单张尾帧图,无 note 限制 | | D8 意图与扩写 | 5 | 反推过程限定在低风险可拍摄动作(登山),未加"他刚与家人决裂"类高风险剧情 | | D9 机械校验 | 5 | 指令行占位符已解析(round 2 修复点) | ``` 加权和 = 100;D1=5 不封顶;最终 = 100 ``` --- ## TS-05(Ref2VA,困难)|智能手表 + 代言人口播片段,产品发布短视频(**重新生成**) **处理**:v0.3.0 重新生成。**七步工作流落点**: - 第 1 步硬约束:Ref2VA(1 图 + 1 视频,双主体跨素材一致性);六字段顺序固定;references= [产品图, 口播视频];意图=代言人抬手展示手表,手表外观与代言人形象保持跨镜头一致;风格科技感但 不要浮夸;无对白。 - 第 2 步素材预检:两份素材 note 均无不可用标记 → 全部可用;**职责分别声明**——产品图=手表外观 锚定(表盘/logo),口播视频=代言人形象锚定(发型/五官/服装)。 - 第 3 步冲突解决:无输入冲突。 - 第 4 步扩写边界:抬手展示手表=用户明确意图;冷蓝 key light/金属表带反光=低风险可拍摄细节; 无剧情推断。 - 第 5 步对白:无对白。 - 第 6 步一致:单镜头单主导运镜(push in);手表 logo 位置 / 代言人特征在 summary、retention、 detailed 三处讲同一件事。 - 第 7 步验收:六字段齐全顺序正确;`` 已定义;references 顺序与 `` 对应; 立绘只作 Subject 来源绑定(产品图/口播视频不另起冗余 Picture 条目);无占位符。 ``` subject_definitions: is the smart watch in , featuring a silver brushed-metal case, a dark circular dial face, a fine-link metal band, and a small engraved brand logo on the lower-right of the dial. is the spokesperson in